ADVANCEDBROWSE SUBJECTS
alive Academy
Alive Forum
Event Calendar
Health Retailer Search
Alive Awards
Alive Web Exclusives
Alive Australia


APEX Awards 2009

Find a store
Subscribe to our Free Newsletter!

Enlarge Font Printer Version Email It to a Friend
Antidepressants
by author Walter Lemmo, ND

Antidepressant medications are the first line of defence used by most medical doctors and psychiatrists for treating depression. Newer medications are advertised as "improved," with "fewer risks and side effects." The truth of such statements is questionable when considering the deficient long-term study of these drugs. Over 90 percent of all medications used for treating major depression are studied for a short six to eight weeks. Most people take these drugs for years. I haven’t met anyone who has been taking Prozac or Zoloft for only one or two months. Overall, antidepressants have not improved since the 1950s.

In a large study of more than 9,000 clinical reports, the US Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (affiliated with the Food and Drug Administration and the National Institute of Health) found that during the last 20 years, patient responses to antidepressants have not changed with the Prozac- or Zoloft-type medications! Newer antidepressants produce the same results as older antidepressants. Anti-psychotic medications follow a similar pattern.

A recent article published in the British Medical Journal found newer antipsychotics (Zyprexa and Risperdal) no more effective than the older drugs (Haldol and Thorazine). During the last 50 years there have been significant advances in medicine, but no significant breakthroughs in mental health care.

Adverse side effects plague all antidepressant medications. Some of these include diabetes, heart disease, weight gain and sexual problems. In one study, 48 per cent of patients stopped taking their antidepressants because of increased body weight. Some patients can quickly gain as much as 15 to 20 kg within two to six months! An astounding 30 to 70 percent of patients taking Zoloft and Paxil acquire sexual problems. The new Prozac-type medications (known as SSRIs) produce higher rates of diarrhea, nausea, insomnia and headache. On the other hand, the older antidepressants are associated with higher rates of dry mouth, constipation, dizziness, blurred vision and tremors.

People do not need these additional stresses when they already feel vulnerable or insecure and natural supplements are important treatment options. For example, the standardized plant extract St John’s wort and the amino acid L-tryptophan have documented antidepressant capabilities. They don’t cause weight gain and sexual dysfunction. My own experiences in private practice support those natural supplements as effective against depression. The scope of effectiveness for natural medicines includes, but is not limited to, major depression, other mood disorders and schizophrenia.

Use Them Hand in Hand

Natural medicines, when combined together with antidepressant medications, produce dramatic results. Together they enhance the positive effects of treatment and dramatically reduce unwanted side effects–a task that has been difficult to achieve for over 50 years with drugs alone. In people with major depression, folic acid increases the effects of Prozac and reduces unwanted side effects by over 50 percent! Several other important nutrients have shown benefits in this area. In general, psychiatrists and other health-care providers are not aware of this kind of research.

It’s important for patients to be properly informed by their physician when considering antidepressant medications. The potential benefits versus the potential risks (including their limitations) need to be assessed on each individual’s needs. The selection of any medication should reflect hard evidence and not advertising claims. People need to be aware of valid treatment options and the professionals who are experienced and successful in providing treatment in these areas. Complementary medicine demonstrates minimal risks and side effects. They should be implemented in all mental health care.

Dr Lemmo is a licensed naturopathic physician who specializes in mental health and nutritional psychiatry.

Source: alive #221, March 2001

Back to top

See Related Content
The Healing Power of SAMe
One of the most exciting and promising nutritional supplements to come to market this year is S-adenosyl-methionine, (SAMe.
Beating the Blues
It's always tempting to recommend successful holistic remedies to your friends--in the case of depression, it's absolutely necessary.
Put the Ho Ho Ho Back into Your Holidays
Depression is sometimes a component of the Christmas season for a variety of reasons. Typical responses to the emotional overload of the holiday rush are overeating, overdrinking and generally overdoing.
Coping with Grief
Death and the resulting period of grief are natural processes. The survivor will get over it. Time heals all wound.
A Prescription for Drug Detoxification
If you've ever taken prescription drugs or are currently taking them, it's time to detoxify! Prescription drugs load the body with toxins. They deplete nutrients, disrupt metabolism and have the potential to cause addiction..
Free From Demons!
One Man's Success Over Mental Illness Mental illness really is a misnome.
Winter Blues
While most depression lifted as they resumed normal routines, some have persistent symptoms that require intervention. Mild to moderate depression is not incapacitating and usually improves after three to six weeks.
Fear and Depression-And the Power to Overcome
My small herb importing company saw a sudden surge in business during that critical time. Our sales in relaxing herbal teas such as valerian and balm mint quadrupled, and nature's antidepressant, St John's wort, catapulted to sales levels we had never seen before.
Are You Overdue For A Brain Lube?
The consumption of omega-3 polyunsaturated fatty acids-the beneficial fat found in fish and fish oil-can reduce the symptoms of, and even prevent, a variety of psychiatric illnesses including schizophrenia, bipolar disorder and depression, severa.
The Heartfelt Life
New in the medical profession thought about the connection between emotion and heart disease until recently. There was no mention of heart function and relationships with ourselves, our loved ones or the world around us.
Addiction by Prescription
The medical establishment's drug approach to normal fluctuations of mind and emotion is seriously flawed.
The Sad State of Mental Health in Canada
Mental illness is definitely on the rise.
Depression and Immunity
Regulating or balancing immune function may be the best defence against depression. The sad fact is that one in five of us will suffer depression at some time in our lives.
Seniors: Hooked on Drugs
About 75 -per -cent of seniors 65 and older living in private households take prescription or non-prescription drugs on a daily basis. For institutionalized seniors, this jumps to a whopping 96 -per -cent.
Drug-Free Treatments for Depression
Over the course of a lifetime, up to 12 percent of men and 20 percent of fen will suffer from a depressive illness. It is a highly recurrent illness where 80 percent of patients who have had one depressive episode will experience another one. Depression, when it hits, can be crippling to the individual and to the supporting family members.
Beat the Blues
Higher fish consumption is associated with a decreased risk of depression, postpartum depression, and suicidal thought.
Women and Drugs: One Size Does Not Fit All

"One size fits all is common in the drug industry, with the same dosage often recommended for everyone. This prescribing mentality is beyond absurd - it's dangerous, even deadly..
When is it Depression?
Over the years, prescriptions for antidepressants have multiplied. According to Statistics Canada 10 percent of the population age 18 to 24, nine percent age 25 to 44, 6.
Mood Boosters
Some people are almost always in a good mood. They're happy, even-tempered, and always see the bright side of situations. They don't take themselves too seriously and they love to laugh. Keeping on the sunny side of life seems to come naturally..
The ABCs of Hypothyroidism
Thyroid hormones affect every cell in the body. In hypothyroidism, the amount of hormone secreted by the thyroid gland does not meet the body's demands.
Down with Depression
Depression is the most common psychiatric ailment in Western society. Depression affects around 1.4 million people in Canada at any given time and is the second leading cause of long-term disability among workers.
Anxiety
Often starting with a gnawing feeling in the pit of your stomach, anxiety is a natural warning signal, part of our built-in "fight or flight or stress response.
Alleviating Anxiety
Anxiety is a funny thing. If relaxed enough, you may, when faced with stress, become sharper, brighter, and better able to tackle the stress you fac.
Death by Doctoring
Antibiotics and other commonly prescribed drugs can deplete the body of essential vitamins and minerals. Regular supplementation is needed to reduce the effects of pharmaceuticals on our nutrient levels when these drugs must be taken.
Swallowing Emotions
From the mind/body perspective, physical illnesses may be expressions of basic psychological wounds, developing out of the emotional defences we construct to avoid feeling pain.
Sunshine For the Mind
Maybe it's one of those cloudy grey days. Or maybe it's just hard to get motivated for the same old routine. Perhaps you're feeling trapped in your job or a relationship that's seen better days.
What Do I Do With All These Feelings?
With Christmas having come and gone, many of us may be suffering from a post-holiday hangover-not just from the drinking, but from the spending, the eating, the partying and the dealings with family, too. So what exactly do we do to not get depressed and discouraged?The key lies in the ability to process our emotions..
Emotional Homeopathy
Homeopathic remedies can assist people who want to work on their emotional, mental and spiritual growth and development. The remedies can help people who strive to achieve a more positive mindset and a feeling of well being. Negative moods, thoughts and actions can bring about imbalances.
Look for Balance and Feel Balanced!
Research has catapulted emotional health to the forefront of wellness. The consensus now is that mental health is the new frontier for peak performance and quality of life, while stress and depression its nemesis.
Dosing the Doldrums
It was the New Year and the fifth cloudy day in a row when I finally decided to give up looking for outdoor activities that demanded sunny weather. Instead, I called a good friend to suggest we hit the latest blockbuster movie.
Moving Beyond Worry, Stress, and Fear
Nearly 2,000 years ago Epictetus, the Roman slave who became a Greek philosopher, wrote, "We are disturbed not by what happens to us, but by our thoughts about what happens.
Don't Worry-Be Thankful
Everyone worries. Will I get the promotion? Will I sell my house? Will my daughter make the hockey team? Do I worry too much? All these thoughts can overwhelm us and affect our quality of life.
Craving Carbs and Feeling Depressed?
Patients with atypical depression responded favourably to treatment with chromium picolinate, a mineral closely involved in healthy blood sugar balance and insulin response. It is probably safe to conclude that most depressed patients with carbohydrate cravings and weight gain should receive chromium supplements. Good nutrition and exercise can also treat depression.
Got Guilt?
You know guilt: it’s that uneasy feeling you get when you think you’ve done something wrong. But did you know that guilt can be either positive or positively toxic? Many people who suffer from toxic guilt don’t have a clue that guilt is the problem. Could you be one of them?
Postpartum Survival Strategies
In some traditional cultures, women take the first 30 days after the birth of a baby to recover from pregnancy and childbirth and learn how to care for their new baby. However, in many modern cultures women are expected to bounce back and return to managing their jobs and households almost immediately.
Exercise for a Positive Mind Set
Regular exercise may be one of the best ways to enhance powerful mood-lifting brain chemicals that may work as natural antidepressants. It enhances overall brain function and helps to alleviate depression, one of the most common disorders of our time.
Food and Mood
The relationship between food and mood is mediated by both psychological and physiological factors. It is clear that food can influence mood while mood can influence food choices. It is a complex relationship and based on taste, experience, expectations, culture, stressors, and nutritional status.
Take the Pressure Off
Many people believe their only recourse during anxiety attacks is conventional medication. In fact, homeopathic remedies treat emotional imbalances without drug side effects and chemicals, and yet do not interfere if medications are needed.
Sugar, Obesity, and Depression
In a study of adults with fructose intolerance, reducing dietary fructose resulted in a 65-percent reduction in depression scores in only four weeks. There is mounting evidence that obesity and depression share a close relationship. Regular exercise can make a world of difference for the depressed.
Ho, Ho, Ho...Hardly
As many as 5 percent of us deal with seasonal affective disorder (SAD) in winter, when the days get shorter and we are literally getting less light in our lives-and to our brains. Fortunately, there are natural ways to boost your mood and help you enjoy the holidays and weather the January slump that sometimes follows.
Hope for Mental Illness
I have evaluated and treated hundreds of patients struggling to overcome the challenges of mental illness. In the majority of cases, the addition of complementary treatments has improved their quality of life and treatment outcomes.
Dealing with Depression
Depression is much more than simply a case of the blues. It is a medical condition that can range from mild to severe, with a significant impact on quality of life.
The Heartbreaking Story of Avandia
Is the FDA asleep at the wheel? Despite warnings from their own scientists that the diabetes medication Avandia has been associated with increased severe cardiovascular risk and death, the Agency recommended (in July 2007) that the drug stay on the market.
Problem Prescriptions
When a patient has a serious adverse reaction to a prescribed drug, she probably-and logically-believes her experience will have a meaningful impact on the health care system. Unfortunately, the reality is quite different.
Pushing Prescriptions
You've seen them on television commercials: middle-aged men skip down the street like deliriously happy lottery winners. Women pass on a secret cure as if it were the key to everlasting life. Senior citizens perform their best Plácido Domingo imitations in the shower.
Diagnosis: Depression
In my opinion, all cancer patients are heroes. Fate has given them a difficult road to travel. Cancer rivets them-and us, if they are our loved ones-to an emotional merry-go-round. Some cancer patients succumb to grief and suffer from depression. However, there are things they can do to face and manage the challenges on the journey ahead.
High Anxiety
Your heart is racing and your palms sweat. Perhaps you're worried about that big speech you have to give or you're rushing to meet a demanding work deadline. There may be another much likelier-yet far less understood-explanation.
Worrying Ourselves to Death
Have you ever tried counting your worries? While drafting this article I managed to squeeze in worries about my gobbled-down breakfast, my half-baked plans for the rest of the day, and what I can do to ease pain in various aching body parts-to name but a few ever-nagging worries.
Packrats and Clutterbugs
You walk through the front door and immediately encounter the clutter-a stack of unopened mail sitting on the hall table, along with a tangled heap of gloves, scarves, hats, keys, maps, umbrellas, and shopping bags.
A Story of Survival Love
Deeply in love, Sara and I married 17 years ago. Three years later, Sara was diagnosed with mild depression, and over the next few years she was re-diagnosed several times with ever more serious conditions.
Remember Rhodiola
A herb that was widely used by ancient Nordic seafarers is still being used by monks of the Himalayas. The therapeutic properties of this Arctic herb, rhodiola (Rhodiola rosea), have also been impressing modern researchers.
Mud is Not a Four-letter Word
Mud has a dirty reputation. Soil, mud, dirt-they're words associated with the unpleasant side of life. We say someone has a soiled reputation. When someone is in trouble, his name is mud. When people are speaking unfavourably of each other, they're dishing dirt.
St. John's Wort
After suffering from depression for years, Kelly Martin finally decided enough was enough. He dragged himself to his doctor's office, and 10 minutes later the Calgary business manager walked away with a prescription for antidepressants.
Caregiver's Thrive Guide
Relieving stress helps you stay healthy as a caregiver—because if you’re not taking good care of yourself, you can’t take good care of others.
Beat Winter Blues
SAD is characterized by fall and winter depression, excessive sleep (hypersomnia), increased appetite with carbohydrate cravings, and weight gain, which alternates with normal moods and behaviour in the spring and summer.

Back to top